In today’s increasingly digital world, cashless payments are becoming the norm. Whether it’s tapping your phone, swiping a card, or using a digital wallet, the convenience of cashless transactions has transformed the way we purchase goods and services. But have you ever stopped to wonder how these payment methods might affect the way we spend?
A recent study from the University of Adelaide, led by PhD student Lachlan Schomburgk, delves into this question and reveals a fascinating insight: individuals tend to spend more when using cashless payment methods than cash.
The “Cashless Effect”
Schomburgk’s research highlights what he refers to as the “cashless effect,” where consumers spend more when paying digitally rather than with physical cash. This phenomenon is particularly noticeable when buying items that signal social status, such as jewelry or luxury goods. Why does this happen? According to the study, the tangible nature of cash forces people to physically count and hand over money, making the spending experience more concrete and, thus, more controlled. In contrast, cashless payments lack this physical exchange, which can lead people to lose track of how much they are spending.
Interestingly, this effect doesn’t extend to all areas of spending. The research found that donations and tipping were not impacted by the payment method used. Traditional cash-based methods like tipping jars remain just as effective as digital point-of-sale terminals in collecting tips.
Why This Matters: Managing Spending in a Cashless World
In light of the growing cost-of-living crisis, Schomburgk emphasizes that consumers should be mindful of the payment methods they choose. Carrying cash, he suggests, can be a valuable tool for self-control when making purchases, as it makes spending more deliberate. For example, handing over notes and coins gives people a more immediate sense of the financial transaction, which may help prevent overspending.
“Consumers should be mindful of the payment method they use,” Schomburgk advises. “To prevent spending more than planned, we recommend carrying cash instead of cards whenever possible.”
Implications for Businesses and Policymakers
For businesses, the study offers important insights. Those that fail to embrace cashless payments may inadvertently be losing out on increased revenue, as cashless customers tend to spend more. This is especially relevant as many businesses continue to adapt to the growing demand for digital payment options.
Policymakers also have a role to play in educating consumers about the potential downsides of cashless payments. Schomburgk’s study suggests that people unfamiliar with cashless transactions—such as individuals without bank accounts—should be made aware of the risk of overspending when using digital payment methods.
Future Research: New Payment Methods, New Behaviors
Looking ahead, Schomburgk believes that the influence of payment methods on spending behavior will continue to evolve. With the rise of buy-now-pay-later services and cryptocurrency payments, new research is needed to understand how these innovative payment options impact consumer behavior. Schomburgk sees this as a crucial area for future academic study, as these new payment methods introduce unique features that could further alter how we manage our finances.
Conclusion: The Transition to a Cashless Society
As the world moves toward a more cashless society, understanding the “cashless effect” can empower consumers to make smarter, more informed purchasing decisions. While cashless transactions offer convenience, they can also lead to higher spending, making it all the more important to consider how we pay. Schomburgk’s research sheds light on the psychological factors at play and provides both businesses and individuals with the insights needed to navigate the evolving financial landscape.
For consumers, especially those mindful of budgeting during difficult economic times, a simple takeaway remains: when in doubt, cash is still king.
If you are a business looking for solutions to manage your cash more efficiently, check out our cash management solutions smarttill®!
Source: University of Adelaide Study, Journal of Retailing, June 2024
